Ouhh, that's a difficult question! How am I to reduce the list to something that doesn't include
everything?! XD
RQG Trail of Cthulhu - I always enjoy Cthulhu stuff and it was hilarious.
RQG - Basically everything that happened in Prague's University. And while I really like Zolf (and hope we'll see the character again some day), Grizzop is great already. It's always nice to see characters that are different from the usual mold, that includes giving a character disadvantages like a peg leg, and a Goblin Paladin is neat to see.
One favorite moment definitely was Sascha's: "I'm not undead, I'm vital-y challenged!" Also the Ring of attracting Undead. And of course LOLOMG. And you're right, Mr. Newall, we could do so much with our time, but -
CAW - but Mr. Crow! XD ♥
Overall I like that a lot of everyone's talk in between is kept in. Hearing this is a huge part of the fun in listening to game-plays for me!
TMA
49 The Butcher’s Window - Everything about the Boneturner is thrillingly nasty and very much to my tastes in horror, but I also really enjoyed the irreverent, flippant descriptions of the later victim at the beginning.
53 Crusader - Amazing voice acting from everyone as usual, it got the spooky atmosphere nicely across. And the things we learn about Gertrude and Archive horrors are very interesting.
60 Observer Effect - One of the episodes in which Mr Sims captures different tones for different statement givers well without losing the prevailing way the podcast sounds.
62 First Edition - Beside the interesting story I love the casual way this gruesome statement was given. Very well done!
64 Burial Rites - Again, nicely done difference in tone.
72 Takeaway - The thing that I like most about this one is the slightly troubled, facetious musing about accidentally having been given long-pig to eat. And the bit about Basira asking for infos together with Jon's voiced worry at the end was sweet.
73 Police Lights - The slow change that we see in how Jon treats people is great. And I like stories in which police is investigating supernatural/gruesome cases, so obviously this episode caters to my taste as well. I liked Basira's character and was kinda sad to see her leave, even though that is most likely a point for her being more clever than most.
80 The Librarian - Evidently good voice acting talent runs in the entire Sims family. To hear what Leitner really was was a splendid twist. Everything that we heard before painted a very different picture and this kind of turning things up its head is awesome! Also hearing what it sounds like when Elias actually
does take action was fun. Because I like seeing/hearing characters being evil.
82 The Eyewitnesses - Like Basira I think Daisy is very interesting, albeit in a very different way. And an awesome performance from Mr. Meredith. Said it before, but hearing intelligent, evil characters in action is so much fun when you're not the focus of it!
85 Upon the Stair - After finally taking a peek into the Subreddit thread I saw some voices who commented on the "factitious" way of reading. But this exact way Mr. Sims reads the stories is actually a very big part of why I enjoy the podcast so much! There are a lot of horror audio stories out there, but often the way they're read is terribly boring. Also taking a little poem like this and weaving it into the overall story as a nicely scary episode is superb.
And as a general thing, I like every time the characters interact with each other. It's amazing how much of their personalities and individual relationships to each other we get from the short in between banter and quarrel. The amusing bits that mix into the nastiness are always a plus, especially black, wicked humour.